I'm also an avid lurker and also ended up purchasing a 997. The test drive in the Cayman at our first dealer visit hooked me on Porsche. My wife and I drove a number of other makes after the Cayman and they kept coming up short. We then drove a 2009 Carrera with PDK and liked it a lot, but it wasn't quite the ride and handling that the Cayman delivered.
In the end, two things shifted us towards the Carrera. First, I could not determine how to fit my son in the back of the Cayman so we could all go for a ride. Second was simple impatience. I could buy a custom Carrera with PDK in Oct 08 and get it in January 09 vs waiting for Porsche to release details on the new Cayman and getting it later in the spring. I realize that patience is a virtue, but I got bit by the Porsche bug hard with that first Cayman test drive in September.
So in a week we are about to be the proud owners of a
Ruby Red 997.2 Carrera which will be a daily driver. In a few years, my son will out grow the back seat and I will make my next Porsche purchase, this time a Cayman in Aqua Blue.
Thanks to all who post at this site. The wealth of information and positive feedback from owners was another major factor in our choice of Porsche.