I just picked up (still awaiting delivery) of a 2006 CS w/ 9,500 miles for 37K from a private party. Car originally was stickered for $76k. With the options you mention, I think it is a good buy given the market. There are a lot of Caymans out there in varying conditions. You will always have people telling you to go cheaper, but if it is the color you want with the options you want and you are comfortable with the price...... GO FOR IT!